Looking Back to the Future
Tony Phillips
Tony Phillips was born in Liverpool in 1952 to a Nigerian father and British mother.
He first visited MAA in 2015 and recalls being immediately drawn both to particular objects in the collections and to the Museum’s overall layout. In 2021 he became the first of three artists in residence at MAA through TAKING CARE – Ethnographic and World Cultures Museums as Spaces of Care. A recent virtual exhibition of Enotie Ogbebor, the second artist in residence, can be found here.
Tony has long been fascinated by museum displays and by artefacts connected to myth, ritual, and power. Through drawings, prints, and interventions across the gallery space, he weaves together the historical significance of objects in MAA’s care with a sharp commentary on contemporary consumer culture.
This exhibition takes a closer look at two of Tony's major series: Civilisations, developed during his residency at MAA, and History of the Benin Bronzes, a print series of which the museum acquired a near-complete edition in 2017.
Quotes from Tony Phillips are taken from an interview with Aayushi Gupta, Research Assistant for MAA Digital Lab and PhD candidate in History at the University of Cambridge.
Writing is a medium of communication that represents language through th inscription of signs and symbols.
Etching titled The Gallery, 1984 by Tony Phillips. Tenth image in the suite of twelve plates, 'The History of the Benin Bronzes'. England. 20th century. MAA 2020.13.8
Etching titled The Gallery, 1984 by Tony Phillips. Tenth image in the suite of twelve plates, 'The History of the Benin Bronzes'. England. 20th century. MAA 2020.13.8
Civilisations, October 2021-April 2023
Tony began Civilisations 15 years before his residency at MAA. During his time with the Museum, his drawings and paintings intervened in pre-existing displays to create new dialogues between the objects on view and their contemporary resonances.
He was drawn to objects in MAA that sparked his imagination, using them to explore connections across cultures and to reflect on the anthropological processes that unfold within an active museum space.
Moche Pots
“I was first struck by the collection of pottery from South America…”
The first objects that caught Tony’s attention were a collection of Moche pottery from South America, on display on the top floor of the Andrews Gallery at MAA.
The Moche civilisation flourished on the north Peruvian coastal desert from the first to the eighth century BCE. Renowned as political, ideological, and artistic innovators, the Moche developed advanced technologies in metallurgy, pottery, and textile production, and created a rich ideological system expressed through complex religious iconography.
Moche Pottery on Display in the Andrews Gallery.
Moche Pottery on Display in the Andrews Gallery.
Moche ceramists created a wide range of beautifully decorated vessels depicting an extraordinary variety of subjects. Animals such as deer, monkeys, foxes, and felines appear in realistic, hybrid, or anthropomorphised forms. Among the human and divine figures, rulers, warriors, priests, healers, and fanged deities are readily recognisable. Nearly all are slip-painted in red on a white or cream background.
Until recently, scholars believed that Moche ceramics were made exclusively for funerary use, intended to accompany the dead. Excavations in the Moche and Santa Valleys, however, have revealed that these exquisite vessels also played vital roles in daily and political life, serving domestic purposes, advancing social and political ambitions, and signalling group identity.
“The pots are displayed in a case called ‘Visible Storage.’ Rather than presented with labels in a specific way, these pots are all crammed together, forming a captivating crowd of faces. The sheer abundance of the pots in this arrangement inspired me to explore the theme of portraiture through time.”
Untitled hessian panel with ink featuring Moche pots by Tony Phillips 2021 (Moche Pots I). Part of 'Civilisations.' Europe; Italy. 21st century. MAA 2023.30
Untitled hessian panel with ink featuring Moche pots by Tony Phillips 2021 (Moche Pots I). Part of 'Civilisations.' Europe; Italy. 21st century. MAA 2023.30
Untitled hessian panel with ink featuring Moche pots by Tony Phillips 2021 (Moche Pots II). Part of 'Civilisations.' Europe; Italy. 21st century. MAA 2023.29
Untitled hessian panel with ink featuring Moche pots by Tony Phillips 2021 (Moche Pots II). Part of 'Civilisations.' Europe; Italy. 21st century. MAA 2023.29
Tony created painted backdrops for the display case, combining faces inspired by Moche pottery with those drawn from different periods and cultures.
Let's take a closer look at one of these backdrops.
In Moche Pots (I) a seated woman wearing an Adidas sports cap appears in the top left corner.
To her right is a Rastafarian figure wearing a large hat.
At the bottom right, a small pharaoh is depicted wearing a nemes headdress, traditionally a symbol of royal authority.
Certain figures are rendered less prominently, drawn in fainter lines to create an impression of the cabinet’s depth.
Elsewhere, the pottery has been fragmented and appears as broken pieces of faces. By including these shards, Tony directly references the passage of time that Moche pottery has endured.
When looking at all the objects together, which ones stand out the most?
The Rastafarian figure, the seated woman, and the woman in the right-hand corner on her phone wearing a Nike cap are the boldest images. They are positioned amid increasingly faint faces and headwear drawn from historic cultures.
Much like the pharaoh’s nemes, the forms of headwear we encounter in daily life carry their own layers of symbolism and meaning. For example, in Rastafarian worship, head covering signifies both reverence for God and pride in Rastafarian identity.
Tony draws these connections between contemporary and ancient worlds, suggesting that we are not severed from the past but rather a continuation of it.
Pen and wash drawing on paper, Faces, by Tony Phillips, 2020. Part of 'Civilisations.' Cambridge. 21st century. MAA 2023.26
Pen and wash drawing on paper, Faces, by Tony Phillips, 2020. Part of 'Civilisations.' Cambridge. 21st century. MAA 2023.26
Tony also created a pen-and-wash drawing that reimagines the collection as an endless crowd of Moche vessels and faces. In the lower right corner, a man wearing an Adidas baseball cap extends this continuum of faces and headwear through time, linking ancient imagery with the contemporary world.
Archaeological Finds in Cambridge
“I was also compelled by a case downstairs… displaying archaeological objects found in the Cambridge area”
“It displays these finds on three different transparent layers, and you can see them one behind the other. This, to me, was a really good representation of time as an actual, physical, visual and visible entity. I was inspired by this case, and in response, created a pen and ink drawing based on a similar idea.”
Pen and wash drawing on paper, Civilisation (I), by Tony Phillips, 2020. Part of 'Civilisations.' Cambridge. 21st century. MAA 2023.25
Pen and wash drawing on paper, Civilisation (I), by Tony Phillips, 2020. Part of 'Civilisations.' Cambridge. 21st century. MAA 2023.25
Civilisation (I), 2020
In the drawing, Tony combined objects from the display case with items from different historical periods and aspects of contemporary life. He visualised time not as linear, but as something unfolding simultaneously across the world. At the centre of the composition, a broken pot and mask lie amid scattered fragments of plates – a reminder that no period or culture is impervious to the passage of time.
These artefacts are interwoven with a range of symbols, both historical and modern. The yin–yang motif appears alongside logos such as Vodafone, Nike, and Coca-Cola. For Tony, these symbols continue the visual narrative of time embodied by the collections in the Museum's care. Just as McDonald’s wrappers, Volkswagen cars, and Coca-Cola bottles circulate through the streets of Cambridge today, this drawing inserts the artefacts of contemporary consumer culture into dialogue with those of the past.
Take a moment to look closely at the drawing. What other symbols do you recognise?
“My main concern was to try and find a way of linking all the objects which appealed to me in such a way that the public, when they saw my artwork, could see that we’re part of a general continuum of life”
Symbols and Power
Works of art have long been entangled with religion, belief systems, and power. Across periods and cultures, visual symbols, however varied, have played a central role in communicating these relationships to viewers. Institutions such as MAA gather these symbols under one roof, and in doing so, the objects themselves accrue new layers of meaning: they become symbols of institutional power as much as they are traces of the worlds from which they came.
Collecting and Colonialism
Copper engraving print, Museum Wormianum, by Ole Worm, 1655. Wellcome Library, 571887i. Source: Wellcome Collection.
Copper engraving print, Museum Wormianum, by Ole Worm, 1655. Wellcome Library, 571887i. Source: Wellcome Collection.
Tony suggests that modern collecting practices are rooted in Victorian traditions and the expanding reach of the British Empire. In his interview with the Digital Lab, he explains that this impulse began with early cabinets of curiosities and intensified as imperial travel brought ever more objects back to Britain. Universities and museums, he observes, soon became “the collecting facility for displaying everything that was known” across fields such as archaeology and anthropology. In this context, the very act of gathering and holding objects, and the authority that came with interpreting them, became a form of power.
Colonialism, Symbols, and Institutions
Image of the Enlightenment Gallery in the British Museum. Source: The Trustees of the British Museum 2025.
Image of the Enlightenment Gallery in the British Museum. Source: The Trustees of the British Museum 2025.
Colonising powers have long used symbols to assert and consolidate authority, and these symbols operate not only within individual objects but also through the architecture that houses them. For Tony, symbols such as the Christian cross or the yin–yang carry potent meanings, and Victorian Britain, like other imperial powers, embedded this logic into its buildings and display practices. By designing museums and institutions to echo this symbolic language, he suggests, “the objects themselves don’t only reflect their own power, but… the power of the collectors.”
“While working at the Museum of Archaeology and Anthropology I was struck by a minuscule Japanese netsuke carving of an old man feeding a dragon. Exquisitely carved, it nestles in a glass case alongside other objects from East Asia, a quiet unassuming study of a seated human figure.”
Old Man Feeding A Dragon, 2020
Tony’s pen-and-wash drawing Old Man Feeding a Dragon examines how archaeological and anthropological objects are collected, and how the act of collecting transforms them into new symbols of power.
He was inspired to create the piece after encountering a Japanese netsuke on display at MAA. He recalls being struck by the tiny sculpture in its glass case, a moment of stillness amid the abundance and cacophony of the diverse collections at MAA, and the “incessant multiplicity of all the imagery that surrounds us in the 21st century.”
Pen and wash drawing on paper, Old man feeding a dragon, by Tony Phillips, 2020. Part of 'Civilisations.' Cambridge. 21st century. MAA 2023.27
Pen and wash drawing on paper, Old man feeding a dragon, by Tony Phillips, 2020. Part of 'Civilisations.' Cambridge. 21st century. MAA 2023.27
In the drawing, objects from the collections appear to spill outward, as though the building itself can barely contain them.
At the centre of this composition is the seated man feeding his dragon, sheltered behind a glass case in an oasis of tranquillity.
Netsuke. Ivory carving of a man, seated cross legged, feeding a dragon. 17th Century. Japan. Bequeathed by Professor Sir William Ridgeway. MAA 1927.830 A
Netsuke. Ivory carving of a man, seated cross legged, feeding a dragon. 17th Century. Japan. Bequeathed by Professor Sir William Ridgeway. MAA 1927.830 A
A totem pole, modelled after the one at MAA, rises through the composition.
Wooden totem pole featuring an owl at the base, surmounted by a raven, a beaver, and a frog carved head-down at the top. Collected in British Columbia. Acquired from Henry Stadthagen; collected and donated by Dr James Whitbread Lee Glaisher. MAA E 1907.450
Wooden totem pole featuring an owl at the base, surmounted by a raven, a beaver, and a frog carved head-down at the top. Collected in British Columbia. Acquired from Henry Stadthagen; collected and donated by Dr James Whitbread Lee Glaisher. MAA E 1907.450
Fragments of Cambridge’s iconic architecture frame the museum.
George Basevi, The Fitzwilliam Museum Portico, 1842, Cambridge. Source: The University of Cambridge.
George Basevi, The Fitzwilliam Museum Portico, 1842, Cambridge. Source: The University of Cambridge.
For Tony, the totem pole and the surrounding architecture carry the same symbolic weight:
“The totem pole is meant to look important, it’s meant to look powerful. And so are the buildings in Cambridge. They’re meant to reflect an authority, an embodiment of knowledge which, in a way, is potentially threatening if you’re not inside”
Outside the Museum’s confines, we see an amalgamation of the symbols that shape and saturate contemporary everyday life.
Screens broadcast fragments of people’s personal lives, a stark contrast to the quiet intimacy of the old man feeding his dragon at the centre of the piece.
The delicate, intricate individuality of each object Tony depicts inside MAA is sharply contrasted with the repeated symbols surrounding the building. Coca-Cola appears five times, Vodafone four, and Mitsubishi three. These images are mass-produced to such an extent that they have become inescapable; they exert a dominance unmatched by earlier forms of symbolism. Power is now communicated through sheer repetition and ubiquity rather than any inherent meaning in the symbol itself.
Temple to the Sacred Automobile, installation at Liverpool’s Bombed Out Church, 2010
Instllation at Liverpool Bombed Out Church, Temple to the Sacred Automobile by Tony Phillips, 2010. Source: Art Toscana.
Instllation at Liverpool Bombed Out Church, Temple to the Sacred Automobile by Tony Phillips, 2010. Source: Art Toscana.
Detail of the installation at Liverpool Bombed Out Church, Temple to the Sacred Automobile by Tony Phillips, 2010. Source: Art Toscana.
Detail of the installation at Liverpool Bombed Out Church, Temple to the Sacred Automobile by Tony Phillips, 2010. Source: Art Toscana.
Temple formed part of an installation that Tony created in 2010, producing “living relics” to inhabit the space of St Luke’s Bombed Out Church. Made over a decade before his work at MAA, this piece further demonstrates his ongoing interest in contemporary life and his impulse to draw connections with sacred sites of the past.
Fixed to the wall are a series of plaques, each depicting a stage in the evolution of the car over the last century. Within the church setting, these plaques resemble an altar or shrine. They do more than commemorate technological progress; they venerate it.
The plaques frame a curious deity posed in a manner reminiscent of the Celtic god Cernunnos as pictured on the Gundestrup Cauldron, a richly decorated silver vessel thought to date from between 200 BCE and 300 CE. Seated cross-legged, the figure’s torso is opened to reveal an inner mechanical mechanism, and where a halo might traditionally appear sits a large cog, its spokes standing in for rays of light.
Temple sits within a broader theme in Tony’s work: the creation of ironic displays that expose humanity’s exaltation of mechanisation and its relentless pursuit of progress. Cars, machines, and technologies are presented as the dominant gods of the past two centuries.
Detail of the Celtic god Cernunnos from an interior panel of the Gundestrup Cauldron. Gilded Silver. 1st century BCE. National Museum of Denmark, Copenhagen. Source: Nationalmuseet.
Detail of the Celtic god Cernunnos from an interior panel of the Gundestrup Cauldron. Gilded Silver. 1st century BCE. National Museum of Denmark, Copenhagen. Source: Nationalmuseet.
“The wonderful scientific inventions that drove the optimism of the dawn of the twentieth century, combined with revolutions in the world of art, painted a hopeful picture for mankind in the coming modern age. Two world wars, nuclear bombs, and increasing inequality testify to the woeful contradiction between the potential of technological advancement and the material conditions of the majority of people on the planet.”
Design for Twentieth-Century Chapel Frescoes, 2020
These designs draw together motifs Tony developed while working on his earlier project Guide to the Twentieth Century (completed in 1999). The frescoes present recent historical events as though they were artefacts from a distant culture, inviting viewers to reflect on the twentieth century with the detachment of an external observer. Framed by arches and adorned with cogs, the ‘sacred’ scene elevates the achievements of innovation and progress, presenting them as objects of veneration akin to a holy pursuit.
Design for Twentieth-Century Chapel frescoes, 1900s by Tony Phillips, 2020. Source: Bluecoat Library.
Design for Twentieth-Century Chapel frescoes, 1900s by Tony Phillips, 2020. Source: Bluecoat Library.
History of the Benin Bronzes, 1984
“My main aim was to comment on how the Bronzes were taken. But I also wanted to comment on how they have been revered”
Tony is best known for his etching series History of the Benin Bronzes, which recounts the violence of the British Punitive Expedition of 1897 in Benin City and the subsequent dispersal of the Benin Bronzes into museums and private collections around the world. The series exposes the hypocrisy of British imperialism, which portrayed African peoples as “savages” in the British press while simultaneously declaring their cultural artefacts to be prestigious works of art “worthy” of display in distinguished institutions such as the British Museum.
1895
James Pinnock, founder of the Liverpool-based trading firm James Pinnock & Co., which operated in southern Nigeria, wrote to the Consul-General for the Niger Coast Protectorate urging the deposition and removal of the Oba of Benin, arguing that this was necessary to open the natural wealth of the Edo Kingdom to British commercial exploitation.
Bronze, Horseman. Given to John Henry Swainson, an agent of James Pinnock & Co, by Oba Ovonramwen in 1892. Kingdon, Zachary, and Dmitri van den Bersselaar. 2008. “Collecting Empire? African Objects, West African Trade, and a Liverpool Museum.” In The Empire in One City?: Liverpool’s Inconvenient Imperial Past, edited by Sheryllynne Haggerty, Anthony Webster, and Nicholas J. White, 104. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
1897
A propaganda campaign soon followed, branding Benin City the “City of Blood” and depicting Oba Ovonramwen, the reigning monarch, as primitive and bloodthirsty, a ruler supposedly devoted to pagan gods and human sacrifices.
Bacon, R. H., and W. H. Overhand (illustrator). Benin; The City of Blood. First published 1897.
4 January 1897
The British Consul in Lagos attempted to enter Benin City during a religious festival to negotiate an end to the Oba’s monopoly on the trade of palm oil and other commodities. Despite protests from the Oba’s envoys, the convoy – comprising nine colonial emissaries and around 200 African carriers led by James Phillips – proceeded. It was ambushed by an Edo military force, who killed nearly all members of the British party.
This incident, described variously as an “ill-fated trading expedition” and a “plot to overthrow the rightful king of the Benin Empire” came to be known as the “Benin Massacre.”
F. Meaulle, The Massacre of an English Mission in Benin, 1897. From Le Petit Journal 323, 24 January 1897. Source: Alamy
18 February 1897
The British responded to the ambush by deploying a military “expedition” of 1,200 men led by Sir Harry Rawson. Although they encountered “more determined resistance than had been expected,” they ultimately captured Benin City, losing only one officer and three men. The number of casualties suffered by the Kingdom of Benin was never recorded. Oba Ovonramwen was subsequently exiled to Calabar, where he died in 1914.
Gelatin silver printing, members of the expedition surrounded by objects from the Royal Palace, 1897, by Dr Robert Altman. British Museum, London. Af,A79.13
March 1897
Auctions of objects looted from Benin City then took place at the sale room of J. C. Stevens in Covent Garden. Reporting on such sale, the Leicester Daily Post remarked that “some of the work was of rather high character for a civilisation so savage as that of Benin”.
Correspondence from William Downing Webster to Anatole Andreas Aloys von Hügel, 7 August 1897. Text: […] I have also just purchased 4 magnificent bronze and brass specimens taken at Benin City during the last Expedition price £50– […].
Correspondence relating to acquisitions from Benin City, primarily between MAA staff and dealers including W. D. Webster and W. O. Oldman. Edo State; Benin City | England; Cambridge. 1897–1923. MAA Doc.511.
In Tony's etching series, this history is presented in three episodes: the bronzes in their original setting and the ritual context in which they were created; the 1897 Punitive Expedition, with its violence and looting; and the subsequent recontextualisation of the bronzes as objects of aesthetic value designed to appeal to Western audiences who often remained unaware of their ritual, religious, and social significance.
10 of the 12 plates from this series are at MAA and were displayed beside the case containing the Benin Bronzes that remain in the Museum’s collection. Together, the plates underscore the museum’s commitment to the eventual repatriation of these objects to Nigeria and its ongoing collaboration with the Benin Dialogue Group.
Etching titled Ancestral Heads (1984) by Tony Phillips. First image in the suite of twelve plates The History of the Benin Bronzes. England, 20th century. Victoria and Albert Museum, London. Accession no. E.48-1987.
Etching titled Ancestral Heads (1984) by Tony Phillips. First image in the suite of twelve plates The History of the Benin Bronzes. England, 20th century. Victoria and Albert Museum, London. Accession no. E.48-1987.
Etching titled Divine Kingship (1984) by Tony Phillips. Second image in the suite of twelve plates The History of the Benin Bronzes. England, 20th century. MAA 2020.13.1.
Etching titled Divine Kingship (1984) by Tony Phillips. Second image in the suite of twelve plates The History of the Benin Bronzes. England, 20th century. MAA 2020.13.1.
Etching titled Shrine of Sacrifice (1984) by Tony Phillips. Third image in the suite of twelve plates The History of the Benin Bronzes. England, 20th century. MAA 2020.13.2.
Etching titled Shrine of Sacrifice (1984) by Tony Phillips. Third image in the suite of twelve plates The History of the Benin Bronzes. England, 20th century. MAA 2020.13.2.
Etching titled The Oba’s Palace (1984) by Tony Phillips. Fourth image in the suite of twelve plates The History of the Benin Bronzes. England, 20th century. Victoria and Albert Museum, London. Accession no. E.51-1987.
Etching titled The Oba’s Palace (1984) by Tony Phillips. Fourth image in the suite of twelve plates The History of the Benin Bronzes. England, 20th century. Victoria and Albert Museum, London. Accession no. E.51-1987.
Etching titled Ododua Dance (1984) by Tony Phillips. Fifth image in the suite of twelve plates The History of the Benin Bronzes. England, 20th century. MAA 2020.13.3.
Etching titled Ododua Dance (1984) by Tony Phillips. Fifth image in the suite of twelve plates The History of the Benin Bronzes. England, 20th century. MAA 2020.13.3.
Etching titled Punitive Expedition 1897 (1984) by Tony Phillips. Sixth image in the suite of twelve plates The History of the Benin Bronzes. England, 20th century. MAA 2020.13.4.
Etching titled Punitive Expedition 1897 (1984) by Tony Phillips. Sixth image in the suite of twelve plates The History of the Benin Bronzes. England, 20th century. MAA 2020.13.4.
Etching titled Punitive Expedition (II) (1984) by Tony Phillips. Seventh image in the suite of twelve plates The History of the Benin Bronzes. England, 20th century. MAA 2020.13.5.
Etching titled Punitive Expedition (II) (1984) by Tony Phillips. Seventh image in the suite of twelve plates The History of the Benin Bronzes. England, 20th century. MAA 2020.13.5.
Etching titled The Auction (1984) by Tony Phillips. Eighth image in the suite of twelve plates The History of the Benin Bronzes. England, 20th century. MAA 2020.13.6.
Etching titled The Auction (1984) by Tony Phillips. Eighth image in the suite of twelve plates The History of the Benin Bronzes. England, 20th century. MAA 2020.13.6.
Etching titled The Lecture (1984) by Tony Phillips. Ninth image in the suite of twelve plates The History of the Benin Bronzes. England, 20th century. MAA 2020.13.7.
Etching titled The Lecture (1984) by Tony Phillips. Ninth image in the suite of twelve plates The History of the Benin Bronzes. England, 20th century. MAA 2020.13.7.
Etching titled The Gallery (1984) by Tony Phillips. Tenth image in the suite of twelve plates The History of the Benin Bronzes. England, 20th century. MAA 2020.13.8.
Etching titled The Gallery (1984) by Tony Phillips. Tenth image in the suite of twelve plates The History of the Benin Bronzes. England, 20th century. MAA 2020.13.8.
Etching titled The Lounge (1984) by Tony Phillips. Eleventh image in the suite of twelve plates The History of the Benin Bronzes. England, 20th century. MAA 2020.13.9.
Etching titled The Lounge (1984) by Tony Phillips. Eleventh image in the suite of twelve plates The History of the Benin Bronzes. England, 20th century. MAA 2020.13.9.
Etching titled Face to Face 1897 (1984) by Tony Phillips. Eleventh image in the suite of twelve plates The History of the Benin Bronzes. England, 20th century. MAA 2020.13.10.
Etching titled Face to Face 1897 (1984) by Tony Phillips. Eleventh image in the suite of twelve plates The History of the Benin Bronzes. England, 20th century. MAA 2020.13.10.
“Imagine taking away all this knowledge from a society [the Renaissance, the Romantic, the Impressionists, Fauvists, Shakespeare, Beethoven], and telling that society [Europe] that they never existed.”
Print I: Ancestral Heads, 1984
In the first print, Tony depicts commemorative brass heads of deceased Obas and of the Queen Mother. Each is surmounted by an ivory tusk carved with representations of former kings, warrior chiefs, animals, and soldiers, all of which carry symbolic power.
These objects function as a visual record, a form of writing, for the Kingdom of Benin. They preserve the kingdom’s rich culture, history, and exceptional technical skill. To lose these artefacts is, in many ways, to lose the history they embody.
Print II: Divine Kingship, 1984
In the second print, Tony depicts the head of an Oba accompanied by two leopards. Leopards held deep spiritual significance within the Kingdom of Benin, a theme also explored by Enotie Ogbebor.
Print III: Shrine of Sacrifice, 1984
The third print in the series offers a glimpse into the vibrant daily life of Benin City. Intricately crafted bronze statues and masks occupy the foreground, showcasing the city’s artistic skill, while scenes of bustling activity unfold behind them.
Print IV: The Oba's Palace, 1984
The fourth print takes us deeper into life in Benin City, presenting the ornate interior of the Oba’s palace. Cast brass plaques and members of the royal court occupy the foreground, conveying the richness of the palace environment.
One British reporter covering the 1897 invasion described the Royal Palace as “full of valuable antiquities, and [a] splendid field for antiquarians.” His account aligns with Tony’s depiction and reinforces the fact that Benin City was a wealthy and technologically sophisticated kingdom long before the British invasion.
Print V: Ododua Dance, 1984
The fifth print in the series depicts a ritual dance of the Kingdom of Benin. The dancers wear stylised masks and perform before an onlooking crowd visible in the background.
Masks of this kind have since entered collections around the world. MAA, for example, cares for an egbo, a carved wooden face mask, donated by Thomas Northcote Whiteridge in 1914.
Egbo, carved wooden face mask with a small figure standing on top. Wood, Benin City, Edo State, Nigeria. Acquired by Northcote Whitridge Thomas, donated by Professor Anthony Ashley Bevan. MAA Z 12090.
Egbo, carved wooden face mask with a small figure standing on top. Wood, Benin City, Edo State, Nigeria. Acquired by Northcote Whitridge Thomas, donated by Professor Anthony Ashley Bevan. MAA Z 12090.
Print VI: Punitive Expedition 1897, 1984
The sixth print in the series offers the first clear example of Tony’s distinctive printmaking method, in which he reworks an existing plate to create a new image that still bears traces of the original.
The peaceful scene of the Oduada Dance in Print V is violently disrupted by the arrival of British soldiers armed with heavy weapons. In contrast to the intricate detailing of the Benin dancers, the soldiers appear as stark white silhouettes, intrusive presences in the space. Smoke rises in the background as troops begin to loot and burn the city, while in the foreground an ominous pair of white hands reaches out to seize the mask from the leading dancer.
Print VII: Punitive Expedition (II), 1984
The seventh print in the series returns us to the Oba’s Palace. Elements from the fourth print remain, yet the scene is transformed: stark white flames now lick up the cast brass plaques lining the palace walls. In the middle ground, five white figures pose calmly before a selection of Benin Bronzes laid out on the ground. They sit untroubled amid the devastation, guarding their spoils.
No members of the Oba’s court appear in the foreground, an ominous absence that gestures toward the unknown casualties of the Punitive Expedition.
Print VIII: The Auction, 1984
In the eighth print, we once again see the brass plaques that originally adorned the Oba’s Palace. This was the first version of the plate Tony produced, before reworking it to create Print IV and later Print VIII. Faint traces of the auctioneer’s gavel can still be detected across these iterations.
Here, the plaques are no longer shown in their original context. Divorced from their culture, they sit starkly against a blank white background. Whereas Tony depicted life in Benin City with dense etching and rich detail, the Western setting is rendered with strikingly abbreviated lines. The intricacy of the plaques becomes even more pronounced, as does the violent unnaturalness of their removal.
An attendee raises a hand to bid, while the auctioneer’s gavel hovers, poised to strike. White Europeans compete for ownership of the Benin Bronzes, a startling display of civility when set against the previous prints that reveal the violence through which these objects were taken.
“It is a wonderful irony that something so beautiful could be made by, in this case, Africans, who at that time were actually seen as a secondary or lower civilisation”
Print IX: The Lecture, 1984
Print Nine was produced from the original plate before Tony reworked it to create Print Two. In this version, the Oba’s head is replaced by that of a white lecturer who now, perhaps unwittingly, occupies the same symbolic position of authority once held by the Oba, flanked by the two leopards.
As the purveyor of knowledge to his audience, the lecturer wields considerable power. In a period when scholarly understanding of these objects was minimal, he is positioned to shape European and American perceptions and to determine their supposed “worth.”
By making the lecturer the focal point of the scene, Tony also highlights the hypocrisy inherent in this dynamic: the material culture of Benin is treated with scholarly reverence, while the creators of these works were contemporaneously dismissed as “savages.”
Print X: The Gallery, 1984
In this scene, we return to the ceremonial brass heads from the first print. The head in the foreground has been dismantled and is no longer crowned with its ivory tusks. Reduced to a fragment, it is stripped of much of its spiritual and historical significance.
Tony uses this to highlight the often arbitrary nature of museum displays of the Benin Bronzes. Objects are separated from their contexts, fragmented, and placed behind glass. While visitors may admire their aesthetic qualities, as the two onlookers do here, they cannot grasp the cultural meaning these pieces held within Benin City.
Tony also observes that the enduring value of these artefacts, even when detached from their original context, testifies to the independence and extraordinary artistic skill embodied in the works themselves.
“It says an awful lot about the nature of beauty in a work of art, that even though the work [Benin bronzes] itself was not understood as it was originally meant to be understood… it still has artistic power and significance”
Print XI: The Lounge, 1984
The bronze figure from Print Three reappears here, now reduced to a decorative object within a European or American domestic interior. The vibrant bustle of Benin City has been replaced by a striking stillness, and the object is visible only to a privileged few granted access to the private home.
Print XII: Face to Face, 1984
Tony concludes the series by revealing the fate of the dancer’s mask from the Oduada Dance. Now confined behind glass, it can no longer be worn and, like the commemorative head in Print Ten, it is stripped of its cultural imperative. The act of looking becomes a form of violent subjugation, forcing the mask to remain exposed beneath a piercing white light.
What is etching?
Watch this video below to explore how an etching is made.
How to make an etching, courtesy of National Museums Liverpool
An unusual technique
Tony’s etching and printing technique is particularly unique:
1. He begins with a single plate, creates an image on it, and pulls a number of prints to form the first edition.
2. He then reworks the same plate to produce a new image – retaining parts of the background and selected figures while scoring out or adding new elements.
3. This revised plate is printed again to create the next set of images.
4. The plate is then reworked a third time, and so on, until the full series is complete.
By using this method to trace the journey of the Benin Bronzes – from the richly detailed environments of Benin City to the clinical, whitewashed spaces of Europe and North America – Tony inverts chronological order. The final prints of the narrative were, in fact, created first.
If you look closely at the early prints in the series, you can see faint traces of the later ones beneath the surface.
For example, the outlines of the glass cases and visitors in The Gallery (plate X) are also faintly visible in Ancestral Heads, the first plate in the series.
The seated woman on a sofa in The Lounge (plate XI) can also be discerned in Shrine of Sacrifice (plate III).
Tony observed that his etching technique imbues his prints with a spectral quality, as though ghosts emerge from either the past or the future.
A sense of inevitability pervades his scenes of Benin City prior to British intervention. A quiet foreboding lingers in the background, making it impossible to view these prints without an awareness of the looting and violence the city would later endure.
“In some ways, it reflects how wider audiences have been engaging with the Benin Bronzes: they encounter the objects in museums, much like in your first plates, then engage with their histories – the Punitive Expedition in particular – and only afterwards consider their original contexts.”
Liverpool
Having grown up in the Liverpool 8 area, Tony retains a deep connection to the neighbourhood, and the city continues to be a persistent subject in his work. The final two projects in this series – Liverpool: Growth of a City (2003) and Liverpool (1995) – reflect on the blood, sweat, and toil that shaped Liverpool, while also offering a glimpse of optimism for its future.
Liverpool - Growth of a City, 2003
In this project, Tony adapts the etching technique he used in History of the Benin Bronzes, but instead of working across multiple plates, he reworks a single one. Each successive intervention on the plate registers the accumulation of history as Liverpool expands and transforms.
The series centres on a back alley in the Liverpool 8 area, which gradually falls into disrepair as the city grows around it. With each reworking, the etchings become increasingly dense and frenetic: the sky is gradually eclipsed by the rising built environment, and the images take on a progressively more claustrophobic atmosphere.
Above is a slideshow of photos of Liverpool 8 in the 1950s.
Courtesy of Tom Brown, 2011
Engraving titled Height of the Empire (I), 1890s, by Tony Phillips, 2003. From the series Liverpool – Growth of a City. Victoria Gallery and Museum, Liverpool.
Engraving titled Height of the Empire (I), 1890s, by Tony Phillips, 2003. From the series Liverpool – Growth of a City. Victoria Gallery and Museum, Liverpool.
Engraving titled Unemployment, 1930s, by Tony Phillips, 2003. From the series Liverpool – Grown of a City. Victoria Gallery and Museum, Liverpool.
Engraving titled Unemployment, 1930s, by Tony Phillips, 2003. From the series Liverpool – Grown of a City. Victoria Gallery and Museum, Liverpool.
Engraving titled When the Boat comes in, 1950s, by Tony Phillips, 2003. From the series Liverpool – Grown of a City. Victoria Gallery and Museum, Liverpool.
Engraving titled When the Boat comes in, 1950s, by Tony Phillips, 2003. From the series Liverpool – Grown of a City. Victoria Gallery and Museum, Liverpool.
Engraving titled When the Ship comes in, 1960s, by Tony Phillips, 2003. From the series Liverpool – Grown of a City. Victoria Gallery and Museum, Liverpool.
Engraving titled When the Ship comes in, 1960s, by Tony Phillips, 2003. From the series Liverpool – Grown of a City. Victoria Gallery and Museum, Liverpool.
Engraving titled Unemployment, 1970s, by Tony Phillips, 2003. From the series Liverpool – Grown of a City. Victoria Gallery and Museum, Liverpool.
Engraving titled Unemployment, 1970s, by Tony Phillips, 2003. From the series Liverpool – Grown of a City. Victoria Gallery and Museum, Liverpool.
Engraving titled Inner City, 1980s, by Tony Phillips, 2003. From the series Liverpool – Grown of a City. Victoria Gallery and Museum, Liverpool.
Engraving titled Inner City, 1980s, by Tony Phillips, 2003. From the series Liverpool – Grown of a City. Victoria Gallery and Museum, Liverpool.
Tony begins this visual history of Liverpool in the 1890s with a plate titled Height of Empire I, a nod to the city’s wealth forged through the British Empire and colonial trade. He concludes the sequence with Inner City, 1980s, depicting the city engulfed in flames amid the unrest of that decade.
Oil painting titled Liverpool, Tony Phillips, 1995. Victoria Gallery and Museum, Liverpool.
Oil painting titled Liverpool, Tony Phillips, 1995. Victoria Gallery and Museum, Liverpool.
Detail of lion and girl in Liverpool, 1995.
Detail of lion and girl in Liverpool, 1995.
Details of buildings in Liverpool, 1995.
Details of buildings in Liverpool, 1995.
Liverpool, 1995
Growing up in the multicultural Liverpool 8 area, Tony became increasingly aware that the city’s diversity and prosperity were rooted in its docks, which had served as a major port of the British Empire. His painting Liverpool reflects on this past, built on the labour of the working classes and, earlier, on enslaved people, while also offering a hopeful look towards the city’s future.
At the centre of the painting stands a stone lion towering over a young girl. The lion, emblematic of the British Empire, appears immovable and monumental when set against the girl’s youth and fragility—an image evoking the relationship between Britain and its colonies. Tony elaborates on this symbolism, stating that ‘the lion is a symbol of the hierarchical order of the environment in which she is growing up.’ Yet the lion also bears signs of erosion: notches mark its surface and moss gathers on its nose. As the lion – the Empire and its hierarchies – slowly wears down, the girl retains the capacity to grow, adapt, and ultimately transform the conditions of the world she inhabits.
Flanking this confrontation, the buildings of Liverpool cluster tightly together. Grand civic architecture signals the city’s wealth, pushing the small red-brick houses of the working classes to the margins of the composition. Modern high-rises appear in varying states of repair, fragmenting and intertwining to form a dystopian urban landscape.
Beneath these scenes, the lower third of the painting is dominated by a section of Liverpool’s dock walls. These walls support the entire composition, making explicit the foundational role of the docks in enabling the city’s ascent during the age of empire.
Detail of dockyards in Liverpool, 1995.
Detail of dockyards in Liverpool, 1995.


